What to Talk About on a Second Date (With a Girl): Pick Up Where Date One Left Off
On a second date, skip the new list of topics. Bring back one thing she mentioned on the first date, ask a follow-up, and add your own answer. Example openers, what not to bring up, and what to text before and after, with the research behind it.
The easiest thing to talk about on a second date is something she told you on the first one. Open with it ("Did you end up going to that exhibit?"), ask one follow-up about her answer, then add your own answer to the same question. That loop carries most of the conversation without a list of topics. The first date was for introductions. The second date is for picking up the threads.
Blurry Dating Notes wrote this after seeing "what to talk about on a second date" and "what to talk about on a second date with a girl" in Google's autocomplete. It's for guys who got the yes for date two and now aren't sure what to say. If you are still deciding how long to make it, see how long a first date should last.
How is a second date conversation different from the first?
Date one covers the basics: work, where you live, what you do on weekends. Asking those again on date two can sound like you weren't listening. So the second date goes deeper on fewer things instead of wider.
It also helps to lower the bar. University of Kansas professor Jeffrey Hall surveyed 355 adults who had recently moved and followed 112 college freshmen. Turning a new acquaintance into a casual friend took roughly 40 to 60 hours together, becoming a friend took 80 to 100 hours, and a close friend took more than 200. (Hall, 2019 · the study looked at new friendships and excluded romantic interests)
Dating doesn't follow those numbers exactly, but the scale is useful. Two dates add up to maybe five or six hours. A few awkward pauses on date two are normal. The goal is one feeling: "talking to him is easy."
What to talk about on a second date: the 3-step loop
1. Bring back one thing she said on date one
Before you go, think back and note two or three things she mentioned in passing: weekend plans, a show she's into, a busy week at work. Once you've ordered, bring one up. People open up to someone who remembered what they said.
2. Ask one follow-up about her answer
When she answers, don't jump to a new topic. Ask about what she just said, and be specific. "What did you spend the most time looking at?" works better than "How was it?"
Harvard researchers analyzed recorded speed-dating conversations and found that people who asked a higher share of follow-up questions got more "yes, I'd see them again" answers. In a 4-minute date, people asked an average of 9.8 questions, and 4.5 of those were follow-ups. (Huang et al., 2017 · 110 speed-daters) Asking about her answer mattered more than asking a lot.
3. Add your own answer to the same question
All questions and no answers feels like an interview. After she answers, give your short version of the same thing ("I'm the opposite, I always rush through museums"). Leave one detail she can ask about.
Bonus: bring back the thing you both laughed at
If you both cracked up about something on date one, mention it once on date two. Researchers at UNC coded 71 couples telling the story of how they met and found that the more time partners spent laughing at the same moment, the more satisfied and close they felt. (Kurtz & Algoe, 2015 · a correlational study of established couples, not a dating experiment)
Second date openers based on what she said on date one
| What she said on date one | What to say on date two | Follow-up |
|---|---|---|
| "Work has been crazy" | "Did that project at work finally calm down?" | "What's the first thing you'll do when it's done?" |
| "I want to see that exhibit" | "Did you make it to that exhibit? I remembered you mentioning it." | "What did you spend the most time looking at?" |
| "I just started running" | "Still running? How far are you up to?" | "What do you listen to?" |
| "I have a cat" | "Did your cat let you leave tonight?" | "Who picked the name?" |
| "I need a vacation" | "Did you decide where you're going?" | "What's the first thing you'd do there?" |
| The moment you both laughed | "I thought about that menu thing and laughed on the train home." | "Does stuff like that happen to you a lot?" |
What not to talk about on a second date
- Questions you already asked. "Sorry, what do you do again?" tells her you weren't listening. If you half remember, say what you remember and check: "You're in design, right?"
- "So how did I do last time?" It puts her on the spot to compliment you. She showed up again, which is the answer.
- Exes, salary, marriage timelines. Too heavy for date two. If she brings it up, answer briefly. For the ex question, see how to answer "when was your last relationship".
- Your phone during pauses. A short silence is fine. Checking your phone reads as boredom. Use what's in front of you instead: the menu, the place, the people walking by.
What to text before and after the second date
Between the first and second date, keep texting at the pace you already had. Two texts matter most:
- The night before: "Still good for 7 at the station tomorrow? I found a place nearby." It confirms the plan and shows you're putting thought in.
- After the date: Mention one thing from the conversation. "Now I want to see that exhibit too. Get home safe." You can add the next plan right there or within a day or two, with a day and a place. For wording, see how to ask her out over text.
If her replies after date two are short with no questions, and a third-date suggestion gets "I've been busy" with no other day offered, she may be winding down. Ask once more with a specific day. If there's still no date, "Let me know when works for you" hands it to her without pressure.
FAQ
Is it bad if the second date conversation keeps stalling?
Not by itself. Two dates is very little time together. Watch whether she restarts the conversation after a pause and whether her texts afterward include questions.
Should I prepare a list of second date questions?
A few things she said on date one are more useful than a list. Reading through prepared questions tends to feel like an interview.
When should I ask for a third date?
Right after the second date or within a day or two, with a specific day and place. If you're wondering how many dates before making it official, see how many dates before asking her to be your girlfriend.
Sources
- Hall, J. A. (2019). How many hours does it take to make a friend? Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 36(4), 1278–1296. doi.org/10.1177/0265407518761225 · figures as reported in the University of Kansas release
- Huang, K., Yeomans, M., Brooks, A. W., Minson, J., & Gino, F. (2017). It doesn't hurt to ask: Question-asking increases liking. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 113(3), 430–452. doi.org/10.1037/pspi0000097
- Kurtz, L. E., & Algoe, S. B. (2015). Putting laughter in context: Shared laughter as behavioral indicator of relationship well-being. Personal Relationships, 22(4), 573–590. doi.org/10.1111/pere.12095
One note since this is the Blurry blog: Blurry is a dating app where profile photos start blurred and get clearer as you talk, so you can find out whether the conversation flows before you meet. → Blurry
