BBlurry
← Dating Notes

Should the Guy Pay for the First Date? What to Say When She Offers to Split

Dating & Crushes·

On a first date, offering to pay is the safest move for a guy, but if she offers to split or get the next round, say yes once and move on. What a 17,000-person study found about who pays, lines for the moment the check arrives, and when to start splitting.

Yes, offering to pay on a first date is still the safest move for a guy, especially if you asked her out. But if she offers to split or to get the drinks, accept once and move on. Arguing over the check is more awkward than either choice, and her offer to split doesn't mean the date went badly. The real answer comes from how she replies when you suggest a second date.

This guide is written by Blurry Dating Notes for guys searching "should the guy pay for the first date" and "should I pay on a first coffee date." If you're still planning the date itself, start with how long a first date should last.

Blurry Dating Notes card: what to say when the check arrives on a first date, by situation

What do women actually expect on the check?

Women are split, which is exactly why guys feel stuck. Researchers at Cal State LA, Chapman University and Wellesley College analyzed a survey of about 17,000 unmarried heterosexual adults on NBCNews.com. (Lever, Frederick & Hertz, 2015 · self-selected online survey from 2008, so treat it as a big snapshot, not a census)

What people saidShare
Women who say they always offer to help pay, even on a first date57%
Women who wish men would turn down their offer to pay39%
Women bothered when a man won't accept their money40%
Women bothered when a man expects them to help pay44%
Men who think women should contribute64%
Men who feel guilty accepting a woman's money76%

So about as many women want you to refuse their money as want you to take it. You can't guess which one she is from the first five minutes, which is why "I'll get this one" plus a quick yes to her offer works with both.

How to handle the check without making it weird

  1. If you asked, plan to pay. Pick a place where paying for two won't sting. Then the moment the check arrives isn't a big deal for either of you.
  2. Accept her offer once. If she says "let me get the drinks," say "Deal, thank you." Going back and forth three times feels like you're ignoring what she wants.
  3. Don't send a Venmo request. If you agreed to split and she sends her half, great. Asking for $14.50 after the date leaves the wrong last impression.
  4. Don't read the split as a rejection. Plenty of women offer because they don't want one person carrying the cost. Watch how she responds when you ask her out again instead.
  5. Turn "next time's on me" into a plan. If she says it, reply with a day: "Then Thursday? You pick the place."

What to say when the check arrives

SituationSay this
She says "Let's split it""Sure, works for me. I'll find the next spot."
She offers to get drinks or dessert"Deal. Thank you."
You both reach for it"I've got this one. You can get the next one."
She realizes you already paid"I picked the place, so it's on me. You pick the next one."
On date two she says it's her turn"Okay, thank you. That was great."
She texts "next time's on me""Holding you to that. Saturday?"

For more ways to ask her out by text, see how to ask her out over text.

Blurry Dating Notes card: things to avoid saying about the check on a first date and what to say instead

When should you start splitting?

Usually after the first few dates, and it tends to happen on its own. In the same study, about a quarter of people who had been together six months or longer said they shared costs right from the start, and about four in ten were sharing after the first few dates. Nearly half of the men (44%) said they would stop dating a woman who never offered to pay, so if you care about that, notice whether she offers over time rather than testing her on date one.

If she offered to repay you with dinner and you're not sure what it means, read is she being polite or interested.

FAQ

Should the guy pay on a first coffee date?

Offering is easy and cheap, so yes. If she says she'll get hers, let her. Coffee dates are the easiest place to start taking turns.

Is it bad if she insists on paying for herself?

Not by itself. Many women offer every time on principle. Her reply to a second-date invite tells you far more than how she paid.

What if she just lets me pay and never offers?

On date one, that's normal. If it's still true after a few dates, it's fair to suggest "you get the next one" and see how she takes it.

Sources

  • Lever, J., Frederick, D. A., & Hertz, R. (2015). Who pays for dates? Following versus challenging gender norms. SAGE Open, 5(4), 2158244015613107. doi.org/10.1177/2158244015613107

One note since this is the Blurry blog: Blurry is a dating app where profile photos start blurred and get clearer as you talk, so the conversation is what you go on before you meet. → Blurry

Take a 1-minute love test→
Profiles unblur as you talk
If your values click, the face comes into focus.
blurry
Try Blurry

Read next

© Hyperity Corp. · blurry.link